Tel: 011 646 4558 | Cell: 083 928 9484 | attorney@moni.co.za

Employers are required to provide evidence as to the breakdown of the trust relationship

In Edcon Ltd v Pillemer NO & Others the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) held that it is no longer enough for an employer to state that the employment relationship has broken down, to avoid reinstatement.
Historically, trust was first viewed as a tacit contractual term (Central News Agency v Commercial Catering & Allied Workers Union of SA & another) where the employer terminated the employment relationship on the basis that the employee breached the basic tacit term of its employment contract, namely, not to steal from the employer.
Later, trust included a consideration of the employment relationship as a whole. In Anglo American Farms t/a Boschendal Restaurant v Komjwayo the test laid down was “… whether or not the respondent’s actions had the effect of rendering the continuation of the relationship of employment intolerable.”
More recently, the above contractual perspective was revisited in Toyota Motors v Radebe & others where the court stated that theft and fraud constitute a breach of the employment relationship.
Thereafter, the Labour Appeal Court adopted an operationally-focused perspective in Mutual Construction Company Tvl (Pty) Ltd v Ntombela NO & others linking the issue of sanction and the seriousness of the misconduct to the operational necessities of the employer it cited what had been said in De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd v CCMA & Others that dismissal is not an expression of moral outrage, nor it is an act of vengeance. It is a sensible operational response to risk management in the particular organisation.
Employers should take note of the above and remember that, should there come a time when they have to dismiss an employee based on the breakdown of trust for whatever reason, they need to provide concrete evidence of the breakdown . To know how to go about producing the correct evidence contact Moni Attorneys Incorporated for assistance.

Download (pdf file)

Contact Us

Return to top

Your Labour Law specialist - Experience Empowerment ©

Twitter Linked In Facebook

Home    About Us    Read Us    Contact Us

PAIA Manual | BEE Verification | Copyright © 2009 - 2018 Moni Attorneys Incorporated & OJB Web Development | Photo credits: Gerry Pelser, iStock

Legal Notice: The information contained herein is provided for general information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Whilst we take reasonable steps to ensure the accuracy and integrity of information contained herein, we accept no liability or responsibility whatsoever if any information is, for whatever reason, incorrect or corrupted. We further accept no responsibility for any loss or damage that may arise from reliance on information contained herein.